Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

Finding a perfect carpet is a dream for many! Because it not only accentuates the charm of flooring but glorifies the beauty and aesthetic of a room. Hence, to help you find such carpet, we’ve got consumer reports best carpet brands from so many popular brands available in the market.

This will help you decide on your best-loved soft flooring. So, let’s delve into detail!

Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

Why Is It Important To Know The Best Carpet Brands?

Why Is It Important To Know The Best Carpet Brands

Among the most viral brands, there are several myths about the best label. Some top brands specialize in material, while others have proven durability and strength. However, all these brands promise to give soft underlay, which will not be loose for long, but a few stand on their assurance.

To find such fantastic trademarks, it is essential to look into the details of every available branding and check their safety measures, such as how often they get dirty or catch allergens, molds, and mildew and how affordable are they.


Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

The best carpet brands are available in an array of colors, styles, materials, and textures. Some of them are made of natural fibers, such as wool, jute, and sisal, while a few are constituted with synthetic strands like nylon, acrylic, or polyester.

In addition to these fabric divisions, there is also a vast selection of colors and patterns that can easily convert your room into a truly personalized space.

However, not all carpets are capable of accentuating the look due to their limited color edition; that is why it’s important to evaluate which carpet and brand is best for your needs.

Proximity Mills

Proximity Mills

Proximity Mill is a top-seller and reviewed carpet brand that has a wide variety of flooring, such as luxury vinyl plank, tile, porcelain tile, hardwood, and carpet. According to official brand representatives, they try to provide a high-performance flooring brand that offers an exceptional price-to-performance ratio.

They are a certified carpet brand that issues CRI Green Label Plus certification and guarantees low volatile organic compound (VOC) carpets, which are also affordable and high quality.

Other than this, if you are looking for a cozy soft carpeting option, then Proximity Mills will provide you 22 collections of carpets, comprising roughly 400 individual products. Their availability in different styles, such as cut-pile, looped, cut-and-loop, patterned, multicolored, residential, and commercial, will amaze you.

Durability Of Proximity Mill

Proximity mill carpets are highly durable and fade-resistant as a few are made from solution-dye—which means the color is actually part of the material, instead of something that goes over it.

Cost & Warranty Of Proximity Mill

Generally, this carpet brand rug ranges between $4.00 and $8.00 per square foot, which is way less than what you are expected to pay for a 6,6 nylon carpet. As per customer review, the performance of Proximity Mill carpets is way better than its price range and has an impressive easy-cleaning capacity.

Additionally, they come with a 20-year warranty, which makes them a most loved choice among several brands in the market.

Mohawk Flooring

Mohawk Flooring

Mohawk carpeting is known for its true products, which have evolved over the centuries. It has a great vision of innovation to give best to their customers.

This is known to add tremendously amazing comfort at very affordable prices and fantastic textures that enhance the existing decor of a room. This brand has one of the best carpet choices for households with notorious children or pets habitually spilling something or peeing over the rug.

With this, the award-winning designs of Mohawk carry a wide section of textured, looped, cut-pile, cut-and-loop, and patterned carpets, and their eco-friendly accessibility makes it a favorite for many customers.

Durability Of Mohawk Flooring

Mohawk flooring is best known for its resistance to fading. So, even if you are drying your Mohawk carpet for too long in exposure to sun or artificial light, you can be free of worries.

Also, Mohawk flooring can handle a certain amount of wearing due to its pile patterns. This makes this carpet brand a suitable option for some high-traffic areas.

Cost & Warranty Of Mohawk Flooring

The price of Mohawk flooring ranges between $1 to $5 per square foot, which is highly affordable in comparison to its texture and durability.

Additionally, it gives a general warranty of 33 years, which reduces the amount of time. Both of these features are perfect examples of a brand focusing on the best customer reviews.

Doma Flooring

Doma Flooring

Doma brings out its most classic designs that never go wrong with the trend. They have a range of exceptionally well-made bold patterns that catch the eye of their customer and the quality that closes the deal.
There are nearly 300 styles across several segments, which commit to being unique and marvelous. This makes this brand a big trendsetter in the carpet industry.

Durability Of Doma

Doma focuses majorly on natural fibers, which is why you will find a number of blend carpet options. This brand’s carpet not only enhances the beauty and texture of a rug but also provides great strength and durability.

Customers have rated it 4 out of 5 for long-lasting comfort!

This clearly indicates that it can easily withstand high foot traffic and heavy staining.

Doma has a great focus on making eco-friendly rugs that are safe for the indoor environment. That’s why it is certified as a CRI Green Label Plus carpet that emits low volatile organic compounds (VOC).

Cost & Warranty Of Doma

The price range for Doma carpets lies between $4.40 and $9.75 per square foot, which is way less than its durability, customer trust, environmental responsibility, and a big 20-year warranty.

Hence, if you are seeking an all-in-one rug that matches your style, then Doma’s carpet is your option!

Karastan Carpet

Karastan Carpet

Karastan is known for its innovative designs and elegant textures. They have been producing high-quality and luxurious products for over one hundred years. They have a huge collection of 118 styles that come in four types of fibers: wool, wool blend, nylon, and SmartStrand.

Durability Of Karastan Carpet

Karastan claims to give a long-lasting beauty with high resistance to stains and fading and excellent strength. It provides endless color and style options that can suit any room type easily.

Customer reviews call Karastan a crown jewel of the carpet industry! Due to its high quality, it can stand in high-traffic regions. Hence, you can surely consider this brand as your option whenever you buy a rug for your home.

Cost & Warranty Of Karastan Carpet

Karastan carpet brand is known for its variety and 25-year warranty on abrasive wear, texture retention, and fade-resistance warranties. It also has extensive warranties on nylon and SmartStrand carpets at a very low cost, ranging between $3 to $12 per square foot.

LifeProof Flooring

LifeProof Flooring

If you are looking for a highly soft carpet with pet-proof technology, then LifeProof is capable of providing you with one.

This manufacturing brand is managed by a big name in the flooring industry, Mohawk Flooring. Abd has gained huge attention within a few years of launch due to its high quality and durability.

LifeProof guarantees impressive stain resistance in 100-plus designs and textures. So, you can choose your favorite rug among these textures and patterns consisting of looped, low-pile, twisted rugs.

Durability Of LifeProof Flooring

Lifeproof carpets use a Bulked Continuous Filament (BCF) fiber strand that helps prevent typical carpet problems, such as shedding, slipping, and easy staining. These fibers are woven differently than a traditional rug, which makes it more durable than any usual rug.

Cost & Warranty Of LifeProof Flooring

LifeProof is a mid-range carpet that lies between $2 to $7 per square foot, which is adequate for the finish and features they are providing in their overlaying.

A small drawback of this brand is its limited warranty and varying conditions depending on the carpet type. Its warranty does not cover pet urine or blood stains, so before buying its carpet, clear all the doubts regarding the warranty and the service they can provide after service.

StainMaster Flooring

StainMaster Flooring

Since 1986, Stainmaster has provided its trusted service with its highly versatile and best stain-resistant carpet. It has become one of the top trusted carpet brands in very little time of its launch, and that’s too because of the soft and textured rugs.

StainMaster guarantees the pet and kids-friendly features in their carpet that are missing in many top carpeting brands.

Durability Of StainMaster

Like LifeProof’s carpet, it is also made with a woven technique. Hence, it is also highly durable!

And in giving it such impressive durability, Nylon 6.6 and a few other components play a major role. It not only makes it long-lasting but also helps to make it stain-resistant and make it able to outlast other carpet brands.

Cost & Warranty Of StainMaster

StainMaster is slightly more expensive than other options available in the market, ranging from $1.70 to $5 per square foot. But this price is worth the excellent resistance and texture it will bring, lasting for not less than 15 years.

The biggest advantage of this carpet brand is its lifetime warranty protecting heavy stains, pet pee, soiling, wine spills, and shocks. With this, it has a limited warranty for abrasive wear caused due to shedding.

Shaw Floorings

Shaw Floorings For Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

If you want a carpet that works pretty well in everything, then this is your go-to option!

Shaw flooring is a versatile carpet that gives a premium finish to a flooring. It is made up of high-quality materials, such as nylon and polyester, which bring comfort and great insulating features to a room.

Durability Of Shaw Flooring

Shaw flooring carpet is reviewed 3 to 3.5 out of 5 in terms of durability. However, the nylon collection is said to be more durable and strong-fibered in comparison to others.

Hence, if you are choosing a good carpet for a hallway or any high-traffic region, then it is not a good choice for you.

Cost Of Shaw Flooring

The entry-level cost of the Shaw flooring collection starts from $1.50 per square foot and goes up depending on your chosen collection.

Shaw flooring brand has a range of collections that cost differently, such as,

  • Shaw Colorwall: A mid-range carpet containing bold textures and prints. It ranges between $5.40 to $6.00 per square foot. 
  • Shaw Caress: This is one of Shaw’s best sale options, known for resisting stains. The price range for this goes from $6.40 to $11.90 per square foot.
  • Shaw Foundations: Like Shaw Colorwall, this is also a mid-range option, having a great collection of nylon carpets priced between $3.50 and $6.90 per square foot.
  • Shaw Bellera: This high-quality product is made of polyester and is priced between $4.50 and $5.90 per square foot.

With these amazing cost variations, Shaw offers,

  • 20-year for quality assurance, texture retention, stairs, pet stains (limited), LifeGuard® Backing, Softbac® Backing, etc.
  • 15-year warranty for food & beverages (limited), all types of pet stains (limited), quality assurance, texture retention, etc.
  • 10-year warranty for quality assurance, texture retention, etc.

Phenix Flooring

Phenix Flooring For Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

Phenix flooring surface is made up of high-quality fibers with Microban technology and remains 99% cleaner from bacteria and foul odors. This brand’s carpet is best known for its built-in antimicrobial protection and anti-stain features.

Phenix offers excellent style & texture with unique striated patterns and modern printing in around 1500 different styles and colors.

Durability Of Phenix Flooring

Phenix is a high-end residential and commercial flooring rated 3.5 in long-lastingness. Still, its nylon collection, such as FloorEver Pet Plus and SureSoftSDN, is considered a bit more long-lasting than other options.

Hence, if you have notorious kids in your house, you can skip this option!

Cost & Warranty Of Phenix Flooring

The polyester carpet collection of Phenix ranges from $1 to $2 per square foot, and the nylon group lies between $3.00 and $5.00 per square foot. With this, its warranty varies according to what quality and collection you are buying. Hence, depending on your choice, you may get 5, 10, 15, and 20-year warranties.

TrafficMaster Carpet Tile

TrafficMaster Carpet Tile

TrafficMaster is known for its versatile, pet-friendly carpets that offer great resistance to stains such as spills, peeing, and so on. It is one of several in-house Home Depot flooring brands that feature patterns, such as geometric and diamond-centric patterns, in black and ivory hues.

Durability Of TrafficMaster Carpet Tile

As per customer reviews, this brand has lightweight options that are easy to unroll and handle while cleaning. However, it is rated 1.8 out of 5 (111 reviews) in terms of durability and complaints about its easy shedding and patch creations.

Cost & Warranty Of TrafficMaster Carpet Tile

The average price of a traffic master lies between $0.99 – and $3.50 per square foot, which is suitable for those who don’t want to spend much on flooring. It also gives a warranty of 5 years, which covers cases of staining and carpet fiber loss of more than 10%.

Dream Weaver by Engineered Floors- Consumer Reports Best Carpet Brands

Dream Weaver by Engineered Floors

This brand option is best known for its budget-friendly carpets, focusing on solution-dyed polyester carpets. It has various color and texture options that do not fade or stain easily. So, if you are looking for a highly resistant rug with earth or grey tones, then Dream Weaver can knit your dream flooring.

Durability Of Dream Weaver

When it comes to durability, Dream Weaver carpets hold a rating of 3.5 out of 5. However, its polyester portfolio is considered to be offering slightly better long-lastingness than the other material options.

Cost & Warranty Of Dream Weaver

Dream Weaver carpet ranges between $1.00 to $2.50 per square foot, which is more affordable than other big options in the market. It provides a range of warranties, such as 15 or 25 years of wear and soil warranty and a 5-year manufacturer defect warranty.


Consumer reports best carpet brands | Summary:

Consumer reports best carpet brands can only be registered after considering customer reviews and the features the brand is providing in their collection.

Hence, to know about such brands and find one that suits you well, you have to go through all the top-rated brands and compare their pricing and reviews before making a purchase.


Consumer reports best carpet brands | FAQ’S:

Which is the most durable carpet material?

For a high-traffic home, nylon is best in terms of durability. You can also expect wool, polypropylene, and sisal carpets as good options for footfall bearing.

Which is the best carpet brand?

As per different rantings and customer reviews, Proximity Mills, Shaw Flooring, LifeProof Carpet, Phenix, and Mohawk Flooring are the best carpet brand options.

Which carpet color is in trend in 2024?

In 2024, beiges, warm golden browns, terracotta, hues, black, gray, and green color carpets are in great demand. This is mainly because these colors match the aesthetic of every room’s patterns and texture.

Leave a Comment